15 Fixes for Broken Grades Workshop
A Repair Kit for Grading - In-Person Workshop
In-Person Workshop!
Workshop Agenda
Day #1 Agenda
Welcome and Introductions and Warm Up Activity
-
Welcome from Ken O’Connor Virtually (5 minutes)
-
Warm Up Activity- Getting to Know Each Other
Setting the Stage for Change and Why
-
5 minute introduction video from Ken, followed by deeper dive with the facilitator around
-
Calm Grading and our Beliefs Around Grading Reform
Fixes for Practices that Distort Achievement (Fixes 1-5)
5 minute introduction video from Ken, followed by deeper dive with the in-person facilitator
-
Fix 1: Include Only Achievement, Don’t Include Student Behaviors in Grades
-
Fix 2: Support Learners so they meet timelines, don’t reduce marks on late assessment
-
Fix 3: Use only evidence of achievement, don’t provide extra credit or use of bonus points
-
Fix 4: Apply behavioral consequences and reassess when academic dishonesty occurs, don’t reduce grades
-
Fix 5: Report absences separately, don’t consider attendance in grade determination
Lunch
Team Building Activity
Fixes for Low Quality or Poorly Organized Evidence (Fixes 6-8)
5 minute introduction video from Ken, followed by deeper dive with the in-person facilitator
-
Fix 6: Use individual achievement evidence; don’t include group scores in grades
-
Fix 7: Organize and report evidence by standards/learning goals or targets; don’t organize by assessment methods or report single subject grade
-
Fix 8: Provide clear descriptions of proficiency levels; don’t assign grades using inappropriate or unclear performance standards
Closing Day 1 Activity Reflection
Day # 2 Agenda
Warm Up Activity
Fixes for Low Quality or Poorly Organized Evidence (Fixes 9-10)
-
Fix 9: Compare each student’s performance to preset standards or goals; don’t assign grades based on student comparisons
-
Fix 10: Use Evidence from high quality assessments; don’t use evidence from low quality assessments
Fixes for Inappropriate Grade Determination (Fixes 11-12)
5 minute introduction video from Ken, followed by deeper dive with the in-person facilitator
-
Fix 11: Consider several measures of central tendency and use professional judgment; don’t rely on the mean.
-
Fix 12: Use Incomplete or Insufficient Evidence and provide support when evidence is missing; don’t include zeros in grade determination
Lunch
Team Building Activity
Fixes to Make Learning the Focus (Fixes 13-15)
5 minute introduction video from Ken, followed by deeper dive with the in-person facilitator
-
Fix 13: Use evidence primarily from evaluative assessments to determine grades, don’t use evidence from formative assessments
-
Fix 14: Emphasize more recent achievement, don’t just summarize evidence accumulated over time.
-
Fix 15: Involve students, don’t leave students out of the grading process.
Action Planning and Workshop Conclusion